Sherwood Slams Baleba's Defensive Role, Urges Man Utd Sign Holding Midfielder

Former Tottenham manager Tim Sherwood has criticised Manchester United midfielder Carlos Baleba, saying the Cameroonian does not understand the role of a defensive midfielder who sits in front of the back line. Speaking on Sky Sports News, Sherwood stated, "Manchester United need someone in there protecting the defenders. I don’t think Carlos Baleba is that guy," and added that Baleba is an "all‑action" player who covers the whole pitch but lacks the discipline to simply shield the defence.

Sherwood’s warning comes as Baleba, who joined United from Brighton in the summer 2026 transfer window, has yet to make an appearance under caretaker manager Michael Carrick. The critique highlights concerns about Baleba’s suitability for a holding role, which could affect United’s defensive solidity and midfield balance. For Nigerian fans who follow the Premier League, the debate touches on whether the club’s recent signing will address the need for a dedicated shield in front of the defence or whether another transfer target is required.

Baleba’s all‑action style may still offer energy in box‑to‑box duties, but Sherwood insists United must sign a player whose primary job is to sit and protect the defenders. Fans may want to monitor Baleba’s development in training and future matches, while also keeping an eye on any potential January‑window signings aimed at bolstering the defensive midfield position.

SOURCE: https://dailypost.ng/2026/09/08/epl-he-doesnt-know-that-role-sherwood-slams-baleba-warns-man-utd/